arabs learn music from greeks comments

 siti komariah binti charlie5개월 전




Woow this song a like muslim 
번역
답글
 · 
15




댓글 숨기기




zaidan hammod
4개월 전



Woooooow



답글
 · 




WoodsLesnik
2개월 전


More like Muslim sounds like this
번역

답글
 · 
11



Iman Allen
1개월 전


The Orthodox Christians in the Middle East and around the world have been doing this for centuries before Islam even existed. If it's anyone that sounds like anyone, it's the Muslims trying to sound like us Orthodox Christians. 
번역

답글
 · 
26



superhelenac
1개월 전


haha , no actually that's not Christian or Muslim that's arab music rules , that's not considered to any religion but for example reading the Quraan has rules just like reading the bible.. 
번역

답글
 · 
3



Michael Sawyer
1개월 전


+superhelenac The rules regarding reading the Quran are nothing like the rules regarding the Bible.
번역

답글
 · 
1



Goth Schaefer
1개월 전


+Michael Sawyer  The Quran is pure evil, how many have innocent Christians/Buddhists/Jewish/etc.. died in the name of their Quran.  All Non-Muslims are considered infidels, this means that they can lie/steal/murder/rape non-muslims.  How can this be even considered the religion of God, its not! 
번역

답글
 · 
2



Goth Schaefer
1개월 전


+Iman Allen agreed
번역

답글
 · 




Goth Schaefer
1개월 전


+Korivassilyou Xena If you knew anything about history you wouldn't confuse it as you've done.  Islam came after Christianity, Duh!  
번역

답글
 · 
2



superhelenac
1개월 전


Islam came after all religions people it's the culmination of God's message to the people of the book and this chanting is Arab or turkish who knows...
번역

답글
 · 




Korivassilyou Xena
1개월 전


+superhelenac
We cannot know who "invented" this type of chant but it is probably the type of chanting that was prevalent in the region and everyone shared it when they praised God, whether Muslim or Christian.
번역

답글
 · 
3



Michael Sawyer
1개월 전


+Korivassilyou Xena


답글
 · 




Michael Sawyer
1개월 전


+Korivassilyou Xena


답글
 · 




Michael Sawyer
1개월 전


We can know that this chant was common before the time that Hebrew and Arabic diverged as languages, so you can assume an early form of this kind of chant contemporary with Proto-Semitic--Before Judaism, Christianity, or Islam, probably when Semitics were still polytheists.
Secondly, this is not pure Arabic style, if you're catholic, you should be able to hear the very significant Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox influences.
When reading the Qur'aan, you have to pronounce every letter in a specific way in relation to the letters around it, and the way of reading punctuation is very specific. It's called Tajwid, if you want to google it.
The style of reading Qur'aan resists non-Arab influence, but the Arab Christians, many of whom aren't Arab, but Assyrian, Chaldean or Coptic care less about Arabcentricism in religious texts.
So, 1. They don't really sound the same; 2. Neither one of them "created" a style of chanting, but rather inherited a style from Semitic pre-Abraham worshipping styles, 3. It wouldn't matter who created it anyways.
There y'all go, hope you enjoyed it. If you like Arabic hymns, copy and paste وحبيبي into the Youtube search bar.
더보기(14줄)  ·  번역

답글
 · 
1



Korivassilyou Xena
1개월 전


+Michael Sawyer
Certainly, Michael Sawyer, the chant style basically carries on the tradition, it is shared just as Christian Arabs and Muslim Arabs share the same word for "God," "Allah."
번역

답글
 · 
1



Virginia Amsis
1개월 전


+Iman Allen exactly!
번역

답글
 · 




Korivassilyou Xena
1개월 전


+Iman Allen
Research reveals that the Byzantine chant came first.  The Byzantines ruled Palestine from the 3rd c. until the 7th c.  The eastern liturgical chant developed in the Byzantine Empire from the establishment of Constantinople in 330 until its fall to the Ottomans in 1453.  It is a synthesis of the music of the classical Greek age and influenced by the monophonic vocal music developed in the early Greek Christian cities of Alexandria, Antioch and Ephesus.  Musicians of the 7th c. imitated the Byzantine chant to create Arabic music, a blend of Persian and Byzantine music.  The music of Turkey was also inspired by Byzantine music, notably in the 17th and early 18th c.
자세히 알아보기  ·  번역

답글
 · 
2



Iman Allen
1개월 전 (수정됨)


+Korivassilyou Xena That's exactly my point! I said the Orthodox Christians in the Middle East had been doing it before the Muslims. The people of the Byzantine Empire (which would be in the modern day Middle East and Europe, given that the heart of the empire was in Turkey, Palestine, and Greece) were Orthodox Christians. It is during the time of Byzantium that many Orthodox Traditions developed, such as our Liturgical Music, Architecture, Religious Art, Church Traditions, etc. All I'm stating is, that it is ironic that people associate this type of chant/music with Muslims, given that it is actually the Byzantine Orthodox Christians that started it. 
자세히 알아보기  ·  번역

답글
 · 
6



DefameTheCaliph
3주 전


This is Melkite tradition ( maybe Catholic or Antiochian Orthodox) which is one of the oldest communities in the middle east. It is likely , like the Quran , was influenced by the Syriac Chants which was the language of the region. 
번역

답글
 · 
4



Yakz Jerush
3주 전


No, its not like Muslim. Muslim is like us because they copied it. 
번역

답글
 · 
1



southwriter
3주 전


+superhelenac Islam is the religion of evil.
번역

답글
 · 
1



Eleni _
3주 전


+DefameTheCaliph Antiochian Orthodox.
번역

답글
 · 




siti komariah binti charlie
2주 전


+southwriter you hate coz you not muslim ... up to you 
번역

답글
 · 




southwriter
2주 전


+siti komariah binti charlie Go over there and see how they treat you. If you want to live, you'll renounce your Christianity (assuming you are one), and be covered from head-to-toe in the garb of slavery that all women wear. You won't be able to get an education, and you'll be treated worse than garbage. THAT is the truth of Muslims.
번역

답글
 · 




siti komariah binti charlie
2주 전


+southwriter i am muslim and at here free 
번역

답글
 · 




Branimir
2주 전


+siti komariah binti charlie Many people were something else before they met Jesus. So, if you meet Him, don't reject Him.
번역

답글
 · 




southwriter
2주 전


+siti komariah binti charlie The Muslims are the terrorists for the rest of the world.
번역

답글
 · 
1



siti komariah binti charlie
1주 전


+southwriter for me not all muslim is terrorist 
번역

답글
 · 




siti komariah binti charlie
1주 전


+Branimir yes coz yesus is my prophet for me 
번역

답글
 · 
1



Branimir
1주 전 (수정됨)


+siti komariah binti charlie Indeed, this is a step in the right direction.
Koran mentions Him more than it mentions Mohammad and He was born in a miraculous way, lived a miraculous life, healed people, had no sin, and even brought back dead people to life. No-one else could do even 1/100 of this. Other prophets did miracles, like Moses*, they could never do this much! He is the only one after Adam, who was born not from a man, but by a virgin.
So if Jesus is the second Adam, He had to do/undo something Adam had done /undone.
This is the next step.
* Since there is nothing impossible for God, all prophets did miracles, this is how we know they were prophets! If someone didn't show miracles, we should ask ourselves was he from God and look closer into his life. If his life was nevertheless in line with the lives of other prophets (but not if he just had a beard like them), then probably we could study him closer. But if not ....
자세히 알아보기  ·  번역

답글
 · 
1



Joseph David
2일 전


It is Arabic singing.
번역

답글
 · 

polychronio
1초 전 (수정됨)


+Joseph David greek byzantine singing in arabic.
번역

답글

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MvjiVam2HO4 ·